Manchester United’s recent matches have highlighted a significant problem for the team: the absence of a dependable goalkeeper. This issue has intensified the squad’s defensive woes, drawing criticism from both supporters and former players who have voiced their growing concerns. The lack of a commanding and reliable figure between the posts has left United vulnerable at the back, leading to a series of disappointing results.
A focal point of this concern is André Onana, who has come under increasing scrutiny following a series of inconsistent performances. The Cameroonian goalkeeper joined Manchester United in 2023 for a substantial fee of £52 million, a move that initially brought optimism to fans hopeful for a solution to the club’s goalkeeping challenges. Onana’s arrival was seen as a fresh start, especially following the departure of David de Gea, whose form had been erratic in his final seasons at Old Trafford. Onana’s reputation for being comfortable with the ball at his feet and his experience in high-pressure situations, particularly during his time at Inter Milan, were expected to strengthen United’s defensive line.
However, despite a promising beginning, Onana’s tenure has been marked by inconsistency and costly mistakes that have cast a shadow over his potential. One of the most glaring examples of his struggles came during Manchester United’s FA Cup loss to Fulham. In that match, Onana’s inability to save any penalties during the shootout proved decisive. In stark contrast, Fulham’s goalkeeper, Bernd Leno, emerged as the hero by making critical saves that ultimately secured victory for his side. The comparison between the two goalkeepers was striking and further fueled the growing criticism directed at Onana.
This performance was not an isolated incident. Throughout the season, Onana has been at fault for several high-profile errors that have directly contributed to Manchester United dropping valuable points. His decision-making under pressure and occasional lapses in concentration have become a focal point of analysis for both pundits and fans. The mounting criticism has raised questions about whether he possesses the consistency and resilience required to be Manchester United’s long-term solution in goal.
The uncertainty surrounding the goalkeeping position has only added to Manchester United’s defensive instability. A reliable goalkeeper often serves as the foundation of a strong defense, providing confidence to the backline. With Onana struggling to inspire that confidence, the entire defensive unit has appeared unsettled. The situation has prompted calls for either a change in the starting goalkeeper or a more profound tactical adjustment to shield Onana from situations where he appears most vulnerable.
As Manchester United’s season progresses, the pressure on Onana is likely to increase unless there is a marked improvement in his performances. The club’s management faces a crucial decision: whether to persist with Onana in the hope that he can rediscover his best form or to seek alternatives, either from within the squad or through new signings. The outcome of this decision could significantly influence United’s prospects for the remainder of the season and beyond.
