Former Manchester United midfielder Paul Scholes strongly criticized the team’s performance following their heavy 3-0 home defeat to Tottenham Hotspur, stating that they appeared to be an “uncoached team.” Scholes also raised concerns about the club’s recent acquisition of Dutch defender Matthijs de Ligt, questioning whether he was the right signing for the squad.
The defeat further highlighted Manchester United’s struggles in the early stages of the 2024/25 season. Playing in front of their home supporters at Old Trafford, United failed to make an impact as Tottenham took control of the match from the outset. Spurs found the breakthrough almost immediately, with Brennan Johnson netting a goal within just three minutes of kick-off, sending the visiting fans into a frenzy.
Things went from bad to worse for United as they struggled to respond effectively. Despite attempting to regain their footing, their problems were compounded before halftime when captain Bruno Fernandes received a straight red card. The Portuguese midfielder was sent off in the 42nd minute for a dangerous and reckless challenge on Tottenham playmaker James Maddison. His dismissal left United with ten men for the remainder of the match, making an already difficult task even more challenging.
With the numerical advantage, Tottenham capitalized on United’s weaknesses and continued to dominate proceedings in the second half. The visitors extended their lead when Swedish winger Dejan Kulusevski found the back of the net, further dampening the spirits of the home crowd. United’s defense, which had already been under heavy scrutiny, was once again exposed as Spurs exploited gaps in their backline.
Tottenham sealed their emphatic victory when Dominic Solanke added a third goal, ensuring that Manchester United suffered another disappointing result in what has been a frustrating campaign so far. The loss only intensified concerns surrounding the club’s management and recruitment strategy, particularly with regard to their defensive setup.
Scholes’ remarks reflect growing frustration among United supporters and former players regarding the team’s tactical discipline and overall structure. The criticism of de Ligt’s signing suggests that doubts remain about whether he can provide the defensive solidity United desperately need. With pressure mounting on both the players and coaching staff, the Red Devils must quickly find solutions to their ongoing struggles if they hope to turn their season around.
This latest setback leaves Manchester United in a precarious position, raising questions about their ability to compete at the highest level. As their poor form continues, the club faces increasing scrutiny over its leadership, squad decisions, and future prospects.
