Following Manchester United’s goalless draw against Manchester City on April 6, 2025, much of the post-match discussion has centered on the performance of Alejandro Garnacho. The young winger, who has been viewed as one of United’s most promising talents, failed to meet the high expectations placed upon him, leaving fans and analysts dissatisfied with his overall contribution.
Garnacho started the match with a glimmer of promise, making an impression almost immediately when he was fouled just outside the penalty area within the opening minute. This early action sparked optimism that he might have a major influence on the game. However, as the match continued, his performance gradually lost momentum. Garnacho struggled to assert himself against City’s defense and was largely ineffective in creating or finishing opportunities. One of the most notable moments of frustration came when he missed a clear-cut chance from close range — an opportunity that could have shifted the balance of the game in United’s favor. That miss, combined with his otherwise subdued presence, highlighted the inconsistencies that have marked his recent displays.
This match isn’t an isolated case when it comes to questions surrounding Garnacho’s form. Criticism has been mounting over recent weeks, especially concerning his attitude and work rate on the field. A similar wave of discontent followed his performance in a previous UEFA Europa League fixture against Real Sociedad. During that game, Manchester United legend Paul Scholes offered a blunt assessment of the young winger’s demeanor. Speaking candidly, Scholes remarked that Garnacho seemed to be “sulking a bit” and dismissed the idea that fatigue could be used as an excuse for his lackluster energy. According to Scholes, what Garnacho needs more than anything is to inject more dynamism and purpose into his play. He stressed that a player with Garnacho’s abilities should be offering more in terms of directness, effort, and consistency — traits that are essential for anyone hoping to secure a regular place in a top-tier team like United.
With this latest underwhelming outing against City, Garnacho’s inconsistency remains a concern. While he has shown flashes of brilliance in the past, his inability to maintain a high standard of performance week in and week out continues to hinder his progress. If he hopes to cement his place as a key figure in Manchester United’s future, he will need to respond to this criticism with maturity, greater determination, and an increased impact on the pitch.
