The fallout from Manchester United’s 1-0 defeat to Tottenham Hotspur in the Europa League final has sent shockwaves through Old Trafford, exposing deep-rooted issues both on and off the pitch. Central to the post-match turmoil is goalkeeper André Onana, whose costly error once again proved decisive on a major European stage.
The game’s lone goal came in the 42nd minute, following a crucial miscommunication between Onana and midfielder Casemiro. A seemingly routine play spiraled into disaster when Onana hesitated and failed to assert himself, allowing Brennan Johnson to capitalize. Though the ball ultimately took a deflection off Luke Shaw before hitting the net, the incident has been widely attributed to Onana’s indecision—marking his third major blunder in a European competition. This has reignited criticism of his performance in high-stakes situations and has triggered significant unrest within the United camp.
Following the final whistle, tensions in the dressing room reportedly boiled over. Veteran figures within the squad voiced growing dissatisfaction with Onana’s inconsistencies, particularly in crucial fixtures. Casemiro, involved in the failed communication leading to the goal, was visibly furious during the game and had a heated exchange with Onana on the pitch. Team captain Bruno Fernandes had to step in and mediate to prevent the situation from escalating into a full-blown confrontation.
Onana’s standing within the squad has been severely damaged. What was once seen as confidence and command has now come under scrutiny, with multiple players reportedly doubting his leadership credentials. His position as the club’s first-choice goalkeeper is now under serious threat, as insiders suggest his relationship with key teammates has deteriorated significantly. With Manchester United reportedly open to selling any player in the current squad, Onana’s future is highly uncertain. The club is said to value him at just £20 million, signaling a possible willingness to move on and seek a more dependable option between the posts.
But Onana’s blunder is symptomatic of deeper issues at United. Head coach Ruben Amorim’s tactics have come under increasing criticism, with many questioning the lack of creativity and drive in the team’s recent displays. There’s also an evident leadership vacuum, as experienced players have failed to rally the squad during pivotal moments. The disappointment of losing a major final, compounded by Tottenham ending their 17-year trophy drought, has only intensified the pressure on the club’s hierarchy.
As Manchester United prepare for a massive squad overhaul under new sporting leadership, the question remains: Should Onana be given a second chance, or is his departure necessary to stabilize the team’s defensive core and rebuild morale?
