The Premier League’s recent decision to penalize Everton with a 10-point deduction has triggered speculation about the potential consequences for Manchester City, whose Financial Fair Play (FFP) inquiry is underway. Everton’s punishment stemmed from exceeding the permissible £105 million losses over three years, as an independent committee found their 2021-22 losses to be £124.5 million. The severity of this penalty, the most significant in Premier League history, has raised concerns and prompted Everton to signal their intention to appeal.
Meanwhile, Manchester City faces allegations of violating financial regulations dating back to the 2009/10 season. The Premier League referred these breaches to an independent Commission, emphasizing confidentiality in the proceedings. Despite the severity of the charges, the likelihood of City losing their Premier League titles appears remote, with insiders suggesting a focus on forward-looking penalties rather than retrospective measures. The prospect of a 30-point deduction or immediate relegation to the Championship looms, according to journalist Martyn Ziegler, who highlighted the genuine threat facing both Manchester City and Chelsea in ongoing investigations by both the Premier League and the Football Association.
While there is a degree of reassurance for City regarding potential retrospective punishments, the looming danger of a substantial points deduction or demotion remains a significant concern. This uncertainty underscores the unprecedented nature of the situation, and the final outcome will depend on the findings of the independent Commission. The Premier League, adhering to confidentiality rules, has refrained from providing further commentary on the matter.
