Thierry Henry and Jamie Carragher have expressed doubts about Gabriel Martinelli’s role in Arsenal’s starting lineup ahead of their pivotal Premier League encounter with Manchester City. The Brazilian winger has come under scrutiny following a string of underwhelming performances, particularly after his showing in Arsenal’s scoreless draw against Atalanta in the Champions League. His inability to convert Arsenal’s best opportunity during the second half has extended his goalless and assist-less run to 17 games, placing his place in the team in jeopardy as the club prepares for such a high-stakes match.
Carragher suggested that Martinelli’s starting position against City, especially at the Etihad Stadium, is uncertain due to his current form. He attributed Arsenal’s struggles against Atalanta in part to the absence of Martin Odegaard, whose playmaking ability and link-up play with Bukayo Saka were sorely missed. Carragher noted that while Kai Havertz was brought in to fill Odegaard’s creative role, he struggled to adapt to the system. This further hampered Arsenal’s ability to break down Atalanta’s defense and generate quality scoring chances.
Carragher raised the possibility of Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta considering Leandro Trossard as a potential replacement for Martinelli in the upcoming clash with City. However, despite Martinelli’s recent difficulties in front of goal, Carragher believes Arteta will likely show faith in the young winger, trusting him to rediscover his form. “Martinelli’s position may be under threat,” said Carragher, “but I think the manager will still back him to come good, even though his composure in front of goal has been lacking.”
Thierry Henry echoed Carragher’s sentiments, acknowledging that Martinelli is facing a challenging phase in his development. Henry emphasized that the winger’s goal drought is part of a learning curve for both Martinelli and the team, who must work through this rough patch together. He expressed optimism that key players like Declan Rice could play a role in helping Martinelli regain his confidence, but admitted that Martinelli’s recent form is concerning.
Adding to the discussion, Rio Ferdinand highlighted Arsenal’s broader attacking issues, particularly during the Atalanta match. He pointed out that Arsenal’s creativity and ability to maintain possession were not at the level required to compete against a team of Manchester City’s caliber. Ferdinand emphasized the importance of being clinical in front of goal, noting that Martinelli’s missed opportunity against Atalanta was emblematic of Arsenal’s need to improve their finishing. He warned that City would not offer Arsenal many chances, so the forwards must capitalize on the few opportunities they do get.
As Arsenal gear up for their critical showdown with Manchester City, much of the attention will be on Martinelli, whose ability to turn his form around could be crucial to Arsenal’s title hopes.