Paul Scholes has made headlines with a striking statement that echoes what many Manchester United supporters have been feeling for a while—there’s a particular player within the current squad who is causing more harm than good, and surprisingly, it’s not André Onana, Alejandro Garnacho, or Bruno Fernandes. The former United midfielder was visibly frustrated following the club’s dismal 4-1 loss to Newcastle and didn’t hold back in his post-match reaction.
Scholes made it clear that Onana is not the primary concern at the club, despite the criticism he has received. Instead, he pointed the finger at another figure within the team—someone he believes is actively damaging the legacy of Manchester United from the inside. Although he refrained from naming this individual outright, sources close to the club suggest that Scholes was alluding to a senior player whose performance levels have been declining while also reportedly contributing to unrest within the dressing room.
“He’s the reason Ten Hag was sacked,” Scholes asserted. “And now he’s already causing problems for Amorim—before he’s even officially stepped into the role. This goes beyond poor form; this is about values, tradition, and culture being eroded from within.”
These words have sparked intense debates across social media platforms, with fans speculating on the identity of the unnamed player. Most fingers are pointing toward Marcus Rashford. Once seen as a beacon of hope for Manchester United’s future, Rashford’s reputation has taken a hit in recent months due to inconsistent performances, questionable attitude, and rumors of disruptive influence behind the scenes.
While his talent is undeniable, many supporters now believe he is no longer playing based on form or merit but rather on past glories and internal status. His body language on the pitch, reported disciplinary issues, and recent speculation surrounding his relationship with incoming manager Rúben Amorim all point to a player whose time at the club may be nearing its end.
Given Scholes’ emphasis on the damaging influence of this unnamed player and the idea of him being a barrier to new leadership, the signs seem to point clearly toward Rashford. He has been with the club for years, has considerable backing, and yet continues to divide opinion due to his performances and demeanor.
The real question now is whether Rashford can still salvage his Manchester United career, or if a clean break would be the best decision for both the player and the club moving forward.
