Manchester United’s hopes of advancing in the Europa League suffered a serious blow after a 2-2 draw with Lyon, a result that has drawn significant criticism — particularly directed at goalkeeper André Onana. The Cameroonian shot-stopper was at the heart of the controversy, having been directly responsible for both of Lyon’s goals. A poorly handled free-kick and a lapse in concentration that allowed a late equalizer have placed his performance under intense scrutiny yet again, adding fuel to the ongoing debate about his reliability in goal.
In the wake of the disappointing result, a Manchester United legend didn’t hold back his frustration. The former player slammed Onana’s decision-making and discipline, saying, “He will never play for me again—simple tactical instructions and he still can’t follow them! What a terrible player. Zero discipline, zero drive.” This harsh critique wasn’t limited to Onana alone; the legend also criticized former manager Erik ten Hag for signing the goalkeeper in the first place, stating firmly that this should mark Onana’s final appearance for the club.
Onana’s spell at Old Trafford since his £45 million move from Inter Milan in July 2023 has been anything but smooth. His inconsistency has been a major concern, and recent stats do him no favors—he leads all Premier League goalkeepers in errors directly resulting in goals, with nine such mistakes across all competitions. For a club of United’s stature, particularly in a position as crucial as goalkeeper, these numbers are simply unacceptable.
While the criticism from pundits and supporters continues to grow, current manager Ruben Amorim has chosen to back his under-fire goalkeeper. Amorim emphasized the collective responsibility of the team, saying, “Mistakes are part of the game,” and urged focus on improving for the return leg against Lyon. Still, public support from the manager may not be enough to quell the unrest among fans or former players who are demanding accountability and higher standards.
With tensions rising and key fixtures on the horizon, the pressure on Onana — and the coaching staff — is undeniable. Reports have surfaced that the club is once again scouting Japanese goalkeeper Zion Suzuki, which could signal preparations for increased competition for the No.1 spot, or possibly a longer-term change in strategy. Whether this renewed interest in Suzuki is a contingency plan or a sign of shifting trust remains to be seen.
Regardless, Onana will need to quickly address his form and focus if he is to retain the confidence of his manager and the United faithful.
