Sir Jim Ratcliffe is reportedly having serious doubts about one of Manchester United’s most debated transfer decisions in recent memory — the sale of Scott McTominay. According to multiple reports, the British billionaire now believes that allowing the Scottish midfielder to leave was a major mistake made during Ruben Amorim’s early months at the club.
McTominay, who was sold for what Ratcliffe allegedly described as “next to nothing,” has enjoyed a stunning career revival since his departure. The 27-year-old has become one of the Premier League’s most consistent midfielders, outshining the likes of Enzo Fernández and Bryan Mbeumo. Sources close to Old Trafford say Ratcliffe was stunned by McTominay’s resurgence and now views his sale as a prime example of what he calls a “short-sighted” decision driven by Amorim’s rigid tactical vision.
Amorim had sanctioned the midfielder’s exit as part of his larger plan to reshape United’s engine room around younger, technically versatile players who fit his possession-based philosophy. McTominay’s box-to-box style was seen as too direct and unsuited to the system. But that call now appears to have backfired. Since leaving United, McTominay has delivered a string of commanding performances, scoring crucial goals and establishing himself as a leader on and off the pitch.
“Sold for a penny, and now he’s among the best in his role,” Ratcliffe was overheard saying during a private meeting. “If he were still here, we might be fighting for the title.” His words reflect the growing sense of regret within the club hierarchy over losing a player who represented both quality and character.
McTominay’s transformation has been one of the standout stories of the season. His energy, aerial strength, and leadership have made him indispensable at his new club. Once criticized for being too limited technically, he has evolved into a well-rounded midfielder — strong in duels, tactically intelligent, and increasingly dangerous in front of goal. Pundits have even compared his growth to that of stars like Declan Rice and John McGinn.
Behind the scenes, Ratcliffe’s frustration reportedly runs deeper than just one sale. He is becoming uneasy with Amorim’s recruitment approach, which prioritizes continental players over proven Premier League performers. To Ratcliffe, McTominay symbolized the heart and spirit of Manchester United — a homegrown talent who fought relentlessly for the badge.
“Scott gave everything for this club — loyal, fearless, and proud,” said one source close to the team. “Letting him go didn’t sit right.”
Fans share that sentiment. Many have taken to social media to express their disappointment, insisting that McTominay’s departure was not about ability but about losing a player who embodied passion and commitment. Even rival supporters have acknowledged his impressive turnaround.
As pressure mounts on Amorim, Ratcliffe’s dissatisfaction could strain their partnership further, especially if McTominay’s success continues. For the billionaire owner, the saga stands as a costly reminder that football is not just about tactics — it’s also about loyalty, identity, and heart.
