Luke Shaw has taken Manchester United fans by surprise with a bold confession regarding what manager Ruben Amorim told him following the club’s humiliating 3-0 defeat to Manchester City in the derby. The veteran left-back openly accepted responsibility for the first goal, admitting his lapse allowed Erling Haaland to punish United early on. Yet, Shaw also made it clear that the exchange he had with Amorim after the final whistle went far beyond what he considers acceptable, even from a head coach.
According to Shaw, his own accountability for the error was never in doubt—he was quick to admit the mistake and recognize how costly it was for his side. However, he stressed that Amorim’s reaction afterwards struck a nerve. Although Shaw avoided quoting his manager word-for-word, reports from within the dressing room suggest Amorim accused him in front of his teammates of disregarding the tactical plan and essentially handing City the victory. For a player who has endured long spells of injury and fought to prove his loyalty to United over the years, the insinuation reportedly cut deep.
This revelation has immediately triggered heated debate among the club’s supporters. On one side, many believe Amorim was right to be direct and hold players accountable after another disappointing result in a high-stakes fixture. On the other, some argue that humiliating an experienced senior figure like Shaw in public is a risky approach that could fracture an already fragile squad spirit. With United already struggling for stability this season, Shaw’s words have only highlighted the sense of unrest surrounding Old Trafford.
The episode has also brought back memories of Shaw’s infamous clashes with former manager José Mourinho. During that time, Mourinho’s harsh criticism of the defender sparked widespread controversy, with many suggesting the relationship damaged both Shaw’s confidence and United’s unity. Now, supporters are wondering if Amorim might be repeating the same pattern—targeting a well-established player in a way that could erode trust within the dressing room.
The timing of this fallout could hardly be worse for United. The club is heading into a demanding run of fixtures, while Amorim is still trying to steady his position after a shaky start to his tenure. Dressing-room divisions are the last distraction United need, yet Shaw’s statement has laid bare tensions that had been bubbling beneath the surface.
What might once have been dismissed as post-derby emotions has now escalated into a wider issue that is dominating discussion around the club. The big question is whether Amorim is already beginning to lose control of the squad. If relationships between the coach and his key players continue to deteriorate, there is a real danger that United’s season could collapse long before it has a chance to recover.
