Manchester United’s struggles this season have been widely discussed, with their recent 1-0 defeat to Tottenham adding to the growing list of disappointments. In the wake of the loss, one club legend has reportedly voiced concerns about the current squad. José Mourinho, the former United manager and now Fenerbahçe coach, allegedly sent a stark message to Ruben Amorim, United’s new manager. He warned Amorim about Alejandro Garnacho, labeling him a “ticking time bomb” and claiming that his presence in the squad could lead to Amorim’s downfall, just as it was said to have done with Erik ten Hag.
According to Mourinho, Garnacho’s influence in the dressing room played a role in Ten Hag’s sacking, and the Portuguese coach cautioned Amorim that continuing to start the young winger could result in a similar outcome for him. Garnacho, once seen as one of the brightest prospects at Manchester United, has recently faced heavy criticism. His on-field performances have been inconsistent, and his reported behavior off the pitch has raised concerns. His clashes with Ten Hag, social media controversies, and training ground incidents have all contributed to his growing reputation as a disruptive force.
This situation has sparked a divide among Manchester United fans. Many supporters agree with Mourinho’s concerns, calling for Garnacho to be removed from the team before his behavior leads to further chaos. The winger’s lack of discipline has led some to question his mental readiness to succeed at such a prestigious club. Mourinho’s warning seems to reflect the frustration many feel, as they believe Garnacho’s attitude is holding the team back.
However, not everyone shares this view. Some argue that the report about Mourinho’s alleged comments is questionable, noting that he has not publicly criticized Garnacho in such strong terms. Additionally, Ruben Amorim is not actually Manchester United’s manager, as Erik ten Hag remains in charge. Garnacho has shown flashes of brilliance on the pitch, and many believe he is still learning and developing. While his behavior has certainly raised eyebrows, it seems unfair to place the blame for United’s struggles solely on his shoulders.
The club’s issues appear to stem from deeper problems, including poor recruitment, tactical inconsistency, and underperforming senior players. Garnacho, still young, should not be scapegoated for the team’s failures. Ten Hag himself had shown faith in the Argentine, consistently giving him important minutes despite the controversies surrounding him.
If United’s problems were as simple as blaming one player, the solution would be far easier. Garnacho is a talented young player with potential, and it’s important to remember that he is still maturing both as a footballer and as an individual. The real issue for Manchester United is not one player but the overall dysfunction within the squad. As for Amorim, he faces a difficult challenge in turning the team around, but dismissing Garnacho prematurely could be a mistake. If anything, it’s the club’s broader problems that need urgent attention.
