In the world of football, where elite talents often cross paths on the biggest stages, the battles between attackers and defenders often shape careers. Alexander Isak, the dynamic forward for Newcastle United, is no stranger to facing some of the finest defenders in the game. Known for his skill, finishing ability, and poise under pressure, Isak has faced numerous formidable opponents throughout his career, from towering centre-backs in La Liga to tactically astute defenders in the Premier League. However, when Isak was recently asked to name the toughest opponent he has ever faced, his answer surprised many.
Despite facing the highly-rated William Saliba of Arsenal multiple times, it was not the Frenchman who topped his list. Instead, Isak singled out a Manchester United player as the toughest opponent he has ever encountered. That player is Lisandro Martínez, the Argentine defender who has earned the nickname “The Butcher of Amsterdam” from his time at Ajax and now plays a pivotal role in Erik ten Hag’s defense at Manchester United.
Isak explained what made Martínez such a difficult opponent, noting the defender’s relentless nature. “You think you’ve gotten past him, and then suddenly he’s right there again,” Isak said. “His anticipation, aggression, and timing are unreal. He doesn’t give you a second to breathe.” Isak went on to emphasize that while he has faced defenders who are strong, fast, and technically gifted, Martínez combined all those qualities with an unmatched mentality, which made him exceptionally challenging to deal with.
For a striker of Isak’s caliber, who has been one of the Premier League’s most dangerous forwards since joining Newcastle, this praise is significant. His ability to glide past defenders and finish clinically has made him a nightmare for many center-backs. Yet, according to Isak, Martínez was one player who was able to match him in every aspect, both physically and mentally. “He doesn’t play like a tall centre-back,” Isak noted, referencing Martínez’s shorter stature compared to traditional defenders. “But his low center of gravity and balance actually make him more dangerous in one-v-one situations.”
Isak also praised Martínez’s ability to read the game and his impeccable positioning, qualities that are often more important than pure physicality. While some critics have questioned Martínez’s height for a centre-back, Isak’s comments highlight how intelligence and tenacity can often be more valuable than raw physical attributes.
While Isak acknowledged that William Saliba is a quality defender and “right up there” with the best, it was Martínez who made him work harder than anyone else. “Every minute against him feels like a war,” he admitted.
This revelation has sparked more excitement around future matchups between Newcastle and Manchester United, as fans eagerly anticipate more encounters between Isak and Martínez. For the Argentine defender, being recognized as the toughest opponent by one of Europe’s brightest young strikers serves as a testament to his skill and determination, showing that despite his size, he is a giant in his own right.
