As the 2024-25 Premier League season progresses, Jamie Carragher has revisited his earlier prediction regarding Manchester United’s campaign. Initially forecasting a fifth-place finish for the Red Devils, the former Liverpool defender has now taken a much more critical stance on their prospects.
Currently sitting 12th in the league table after 12 matches, Manchester United finds themselves six points off the top-four positions. Despite the arrival of Ruben Amorim as head coach, which has sparked some hope for improvement, Carragher remains doubtful about their ability to secure a strong finish this season. Speaking on *Sky Sports*, he admitted to reevaluating his preseason predictions. “Predicting Manchester United to finish fifth was a mistake,” Carragher said. “I don’t see them having any chance of ending the season in fifth. To be honest, I’d be surprised if they even make it into the top six.”
Carragher highlighted the superior form and consistency of the teams currently in the top four, arguing that United lacks the quality to overtake them in the standings. He acknowledged, however, that a top-six finish could still be achievable if Amorim can galvanize his players and bring about a significant turnaround.
The Portuguese manager has already shown glimpses of his potential impact, particularly in United’s recent 3-2 win over Bodo/Glimt in the Europa League. While the performance hinted at what the team might be capable of under Amorim’s guidance, the road ahead remains challenging. Transforming this inconsistent and underwhelming squad into a competitive and cohesive unit will require substantial work.
Ultimately, Carragher’s reassessment reflects the uphill battle Manchester United faces to salvage their season, with any hopes of securing a top-six finish heavily dependent on Amorim’s ability to inspire a swift and effective revival.
