Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett has called for a change in regulations, asserting that VAR unfairly penalized Anthony Taylor by awarding Manchester City a crucial penalty in their 4–4 draw with Chelsea. The match at Stamford Bridge unfolded as a thrilling ninety-minute spectacle, potentially destined to be an instant Premier League classic.
The intense game saw both teams aggressively pursuing goals from the opening whistle, with numerous dramatic moments. The most contentious incident arose in the first half when Taylor’s decision to penalize Marc Cucurella for a foul on Erling Haaland in the box was confirmed by VAR, resulting in a penalty kick for City.
While VAR appeared to focus on Cucurella’s actions as the ball entered the box, replays suggested a mutual shirt-tugging between both players. Despite this, Taylor’s on-field decision was upheld by VAR, and Haaland successfully converted the penalty, giving City the lead.
Hackett contends that the VAR official’s failure to deem the mistake “clear and obvious” played a role in the decision not being overturned. The 79-year-old argues for the repeal of this provision, as it can hinder the correction of certain decisions.
In a Telegraph article, Hackett expressed his viewpoint, stating, “One of the nation’s top referees, Taylor, decisively pointed to the spot without hesitation, but I believe he needed a second look. This is where I find VAR problematic. What Taylor saw from his vantage point is unknown, and while he likely missed Haaland’s contact, he did witness Cucurella’s foul. The VAR should have alerted Taylor that he needed a second look at the incident.”
Hackett’s critique centers on the communication breakdown between on-field officials and VAR, emphasizing the importance of ensuring that referees have the opportunity to review critical moments to maintain the integrity of decision-making in football.
